A review of the history of studying the Permian bony fish of European Russia

A.S. Bakaev

Borissiak Paleontological Institute, Russian Academy of Sciences, Moscow, 117647 Russia

E-mail: alexandr.bakaev.1992@mail.ru

Received April 6, 2022

REVIEW ARTICLE

Full text PDF

DOI: 10.26907/2542-064X.2022.3.475-500

For citation: Bakaev A.S. A review of the history of studying the Permian bony fish of European Russia. Uchenye Zapiski Kazanskogo Universiteta. Seriya Estestvennye Nauki, 2022, vol. 164, no. 3, pp. 475–500. doi: 10.26907/2542-064X.2022.3.475-500. (In Russian)

Abstract

This article reviews the history of research on bony fish from the Permian of European Russia, summarizing the key findings that enable a deeper understanding of their evolution.

The following three stages were singled out: primary data acquisition (from the first half to the end of the 19th century), compilation of the obtained data (from the early 20th century to the 1960s), and in-depth analysis of the accumulated data pool (from the 1970s to the early 21st century). The first stage began with the early published descriptions of the Permian fish remains from copper sandstones. These descriptions were also expanded by impressive studies performed by many famous scientists of the 19th century (J.G. Fischer von Waldheim, E. Eichwald, R.I. Murchison, and others) who searched for other animal and plant remains in this locality. In the second stage, the accumulated data were classified as a response to the advances in taxonomy and stratigraphy. The descriptions became more detailed: they were often supplemented with drawings and references to both systematic positions of the identified taxa and stratigraphic positions of the bone-bearing rocks based on the first regional stratigraphic schemes. During that time, the largest contributors to the study of the bony fish fauna of the region were B.P. Krotov, A.V. Khabakov, and L.S. Berg. The current stage is associated with the geological surveys that have been carried out in the region since the second half of the 20th century. They proved to be helpful for the excavation, dating, and subsequent analysis of fish remains. The most important findings were made by A.V. Minikh, M.G. Minikh, D.N. Esin, and D.I. Yankevich.

This review is of high value because it presents the major events in the history of studying bony fish from the Permian of European Russia as a three-phased process, as well as discusses the main achievements, problems, and gaps related to it.

Keywords: Osteichthyes, Permian, East European Platform, Russia

Acknowledgments. A.O. Ivanov (Associate Professor at the Department of Sedimentary Geology, Institute of Earth Sciences, St. Petersburg State University) is gratefully acknowledged for his valuable suggestions and advice during the manuscript preparation.

References

1. Efremov I.A. Fauna nazemnykh pozvonochnykh v permskikh medistykh peschanikakh Zapadnogo Priural’ya [Fauna of Terrestrial Vertebrates in the Permian Copper Sandstones of the Western Cis-Urals]. Moscow, Izd. Akad. Nauk SSSR, 1954. 416 p. Tr. Paleontol. Inst. Akad. Nauk SSSR, vol. 54. (In Russian)
2. Naugolnykh S.V. The Upper Permian flora from the copper sandstones of the Cis-Urals. VM-Novitates. Nov. Geol. Muz. im. V.I. Vernadskogo, 2002, no. 8. 48 p. (In Russian)
3. Goldina R.D. Drevnyaya i srednevekovaya istoriya udmurtskogo naroda [The Ancient and Medieval History of the Udmurts]. Izhevsk, Izd. Udm. Univ., 1999. 463 p. (In Russian)
4. Fischer von Waldheim J.G. Notice sur quelques animaux fossiles de la Russie. Nouv. mém. Soc. imp. nat. Moscou, 1829, vol. 1, pp. 284–291. (In French)
5. Esin D.N. The history of the study of actinopterygians from the Permian and Triassic of the East European Platform and the Urals. Byull. MOIP Otd. Geol., 1991, vol. 66, no. 5, pp. 73–83. (In Russian)
6. Fischer von Waldheim J.G. Recherches sur les ossemens fossiles de la Russie. II. Lettre a M. Louis Agassiz, professeur a Neuchatel… sur deux poissons fossiles. Moscow, A. Semen, 1838. 13 p. (In French)
7. Fischer von Waldheim J.G. Nachtrag zu Hrn. Major von Qualen’s Geognostischen Beytraegen zur Kenntniss des westlichen Urals, cf. Bullet. 1840 N. IV. P. 391, die eingesandten organischen Ueberreste betreffend. Bull. Soc. Imp. Nat. Moscou, 1840, Bd. 13, H. 1, S. 488–494. (In German)
8. Fischer von Waldheim J.G. Zweiter Nachtrag zu den von Hrn. Major von Qualen am westlichen Abhange des Urals gesammelten Versteinerungen. Bull. Soc. Imp. Nat. Moscou, 1842, Bd. 15, H. 2, pp. 462–469. (In German)
9. Murchison, R.I., de Verneuil, E., von Keyserling, A. The Geology of Russia in Europe and the Ural Mountains. Vol. 1: Geology. London, John Murray, 1845. 806 p.
10. Eichwald E. Polnyi kurs geologicheskikh nauk preimushchestvenno v otnoshenii k Rossii. Ch. 2. Geognoziya preimushchestvenno v otnoshenii k Rossii [A Full Course of Geological Sciences, Mainly in Relation to Russia. Pt. 2. Geognosy, Mainly in Relation to Russia]. St. Petersburg, Tip. K. Vingebera, 1846. 572 p. (In Russian)
11. Eichwald E. Beitrag zur geographischen Verbreitung der fossilen Thiere Russlands. Alte Periode (Fortsetzung und Schluss, s. Bulletin 1857, N. 1, pag. 192.). Bull. Soc. Imp. Nat. Moscou, 1857, Bd. 30, H. 3, S. 305–354. (In German)
12. Fischer von Waldheim J.G. Dem Ausschusse des Werner-Festes zur Feier des hundertjährigen Geburtstags Abraham Gottlob Werner’s am 25sten September 1850: Kurze Beschreibung eines fossilen Fisches Trachelacanthus. Moskwa, Buchdr. A. Semen, 1850. 11 S. (In German)
13. Fischer von Waldheim J.G. Ommatolampes et Trachelacanthus, genera piscium fossilium nova in literis celebrimo vivo excellentissimo domino Dri Eduardo ab Echwald. Mosquae, Typ. A. Semen, 1851. 8 p. (In Latin)
14. Lisenko I. A brief report on the discovery of Lepidotus striatus fish imprints in sandstones of the Permian system in 1852. Gorn. Zh., 1854, pt. 1, book 2, pp. 247–256. (In Russian)
15. Agassiz L. Recherches sur les Poissons fossiles. T. 5. Neuchâtel et Soleure, Imprimerie de Petitpierre, 1833–1843. 122 p. (In French)
16. Planer D. On the fossil fish found in the sandstone of the Perm region. Gorn. Zh., 1854, pt. 3, vol. 7, pp. 98–103. (In Russian)
17. Eichwald E. Lethaea Rossica ou, paleontologie de la Russie. T. 1: Ancienne periode, en Deux sections. Stuttgart, E. Schweizerbart, 1860. 1656 p. (In French)
18. Geinitz H.B. Nachtrage zur Dyas. I. Mitt. K. Mineral.-Geol. Praehist. Mus. Dresden, 1880, H. 3. 43 S. (In German)
19. Nechaev A.V. The fauna of the Permian deposits of the eastern zone of European Russia. Tr. O-va. Estestvoispyt. Imp. Kazan. Univ., 1894, vol. 27, no. 4. 503 p. (In Russian)
20. Krotov B.P. Fishes from the Permian deposits of Russia. Tr. O-va. Estestvoispyt. Imp. Kazan. Univ., 1904, vol. 38, no. 3. 40 p. (In Russian)
21. Khabakov A.V. On the diagnosis of Acrolepis murchisoni Fisch. and Acrolepis rhombifera Fisch. Izv. Geol. Kom., 1924, vol. 43, no. 9, pp. 124–127. (In Russian)
22. Khabakov A.V. On the presence of the genus Atherstonia A. Smith Woodward. in the Upper Permian deposits of European Russia. Izv. Geol. Kom., 1927, vol. 46, no. 10, pp. 1281–1292. (In Russian)
23. Khabakov A.V. On the facies distribution of the fish fauna in the Upper Permian deposits of European Russia. Geol. Vestn., 1927, vol. 5, nos. 4–5, pp. 36–39. (In Russian)
24. Chabakov A.V. Synopsis of the ichthiofauna of the Permian deposits of Russia. Mém. Soc. Russ. Minéral., 1927, vol. 56, no. 1, pp. 199–213.
25. Khabakov A.V. Class Pisces, fish. In: Atlas rukovodyashchikh form iskopaemykh faun SSSR [The Atlas of Guide Forms of Fossil Faunas of the USSR]. Vol. 6: Permian system. Leningrad, Moscow, GONTI SSSR, 1939, pp. 206–216. (In Russian)
26. Berg L.S. Two new genera from Palaoniscidae, Eurynotoides, and Amblipterina from the Upper Permian deposits of Kargaly. Izv. Akad. Nauk SSSR. Ser. Biol., 1940, no. 3, pp. 414–419. (In Russian)
27. Esin D.N. Some Upper Permian paleoniscids from the collection of the Geological and Mineralogical Museum of Kazan University. Byull. MOIP. Otd. Geol., 1995, vol. 70, no. 1, pp. 69–90. (In Russian)
28. Solodukho M.G. The findings of the representatives of the family Platysomidae in the Upper Kazanian deposits near the village of Pechishchi (Tatar ASSR). Uchenye Zapiski Kazanskogo Universiteta, 1951, vol. 3, no. 1, pp. 157–159. (In Russian)
29. Silantiev V.V., Kotlyar G.V., Zorina S.O., Golubev V.K., Liberman V.B. The geological setting and Permian stratigraphy of the Volga and Kama river regions. In: Type and Reference Sections of the Middle and Upper Permian of the Volga and Kama River Regions. A Field Guidebook of XVIII Int. Congress on Carboniferous and Permian. Kazan, Kazan Univ. Press, 2015. pp. 10–23.
30. Berg A.S., Kazantseva A.A., Obruchev D.V. Superorder Palaeonisci. Paleoniscids. In: Osnovy paleontologii. Spravochnik dlya paleontologov i geologov SSSR [Fundamentals of Paleontology. A Handbook for Paleontologists and Geologists of the USSR]. Vol.: Jawless, fish. Moscow, Nauka, 1964, pp. 336–395. (In Russian)
31. Minikh M.G., Minikh A.V., Andrushkevich S.O. An overview of the current coverage of the Middle and Late Permian ichthyofauna of Eastern Europe in the stratigraphic aspect. Nedra Povolzh’ya Prikaspiya, 2019, no. 98, pp. 51–64. (In Russian)
32. Molostovskii E.A., Minikh A.V. (Eds.) Tatarskiye sloi reki Sukhony [Tatarian Beds of the Sukhona River]. Saratov, Nauchn. Kniga, 2001. 204 p. (In Russian)
33. Minikh M.G. Triasovye dvoyakodyshashchie ryby vostoka Evropeiskoi chasti SSSR [Triassic Lungfish of the East of the European Part of the USSR]. Saratov, Izd. Sarat. Univ., 1977. 96 p. (In Russian)
34. Minikh M.G. The first finding of a lungfish dental plate in the Upper Permian of the USSR. Paleontol. Zh., 1989, no. 1, pp. 121–123. (In Russian)
35. Minikh A.V. Novyi rod paleoniskov iz pozdney permi Yuzhnogo Priural’ya [A New Genus of Paleoniscids from the Late Permian of the Southern Cis-Urals]. Saratov, Izd. Sarat. Univ., 1986. 13 p. Deposited with VINITI on April 18, 1986, no. 2837-V. (In Russian)
36. Minikh A.V., Minikh M.G. Novyi otryad lucheperykh iz verkhnei permi Russkoi platformy [A New Order of Ray-Finned Fish from the Upper Permian of the Russian Platform]. Saratov, Izd. Sarat. Univ., 1986. 23 p. Deposited with VINITI on April 18, 1986, no. 2839-V86. (In Russian)
37. Minikh M.G. Vysokotelye ryby iz medistykh peschanikov Priural’ya [Deep-Bodied Fish from the Copper Sandstones of the Cis-Urals]. Saratov, Izd. Sarat. Univ., 1986. 27 p. Deposited with VINITI on April 18, 1986, no. 2838-V86. (In Russian)
38. Minikh M.G., Minikh A.V. The features of Late Permian and Triassic fish burials. In: Kuleva G.V., Ochev V.G. (Eds.) Teoriya i opyt tafonomii: Mezhvuz. nauch. sb. [The Theory and Experience of Taphonomy: An Interuniversity Collection of Scientific Articles]. Saratov, Izd. Sarat. Univ., 1989, pp. 82–91. (In Russian)
39. Esin D.N. Methods for studying and taxonomic value of the scale cover of paleoniscids (based on fish from the Upper Permian of the Orenburg region. Byull. MOIP. Otd. Geol., 1989, vol. 63, no. 4, p. 121. (In Russian)
40. Esin D.N. Scales of polypterids (ray-finned fish) in the Upper Permian deposits of the East European Platform and the problem of the geological history of this group. Byull. MOIP. Otd. Geol., 1989, vol. 64, no. 5, pp. 128–129. (In Russian)
41. Selezneva A.A. Evenkia — Ancestor of Polypterus (Actinopterygii). Paleontol. J., 1985, vol. 19, pp. 1–6.
42. Minikh A.V. A new palaeoniscid from the Late Permian of the East European Platform. Paleontol. Zh., 1990, no. 3, pp. 71–76. (In Russian)
43. Minikh M.G., Minikh A.V. Revision of some paleoniscids and new fish from the Upper Permian of the East European Platform and their potential use in stratigraphy. In: Aleshechkin O.I. (Ed.) Voprosy geologii Yuzhnogo Urala i Nizhnego Povolzh’ya: Sb. nauch. tr. [Problems of the Geology of the Southern Urals and the Lower Volga Region: A Collection of Scientific Articles]. Saratov, Izd. Sarat. Univ., 1990, pp. 84–104. (In Russian)
44. Esin D.N. The scale cover of Amblypterina costata (Eichwald) and the taxonomy of paleoniscids based on isolated scales. Paleontol. Zh., 1990, no. 2, pp. 89–96. (In Russian)
45. Esin D.N. New data on the holotype of Acrolepis murchisoni (Fischer). Tr. Gos. Geol. Muz. im. Vernadskogo, 1991, no. 1, pp. 138–142. (In Russian)
46. Minikh M.G. New deep-bodied fish from the Upper Permian deposits of the East European Platform. In: Voprosy paleontologii [Problems of Paleontology]. St. Petersburg, Izd. S.-Peterb. Univ., 1992, pp. 137–146. (In Russian)
47. Esin D.N. New species of deep-bodied actinopterygians (Platysomidae) from the Upper Permian of the East European Platform. Paleontol. Zh., 1993, no. 3, pp. 128–132. (In Russian)
48. Esin D.N. Development of the scale cover of paleoniscids in ontogeny. Byull. MOIP. Otd. Geol., 1993, vol. 68, no. 2, p. 139. (In Russian)
49. Esin D.N. Ontogenetic development of the squamation in some palaeoniscoid fishes. Bull. Mus. Nat. Hist. Ser. 4, 1995, vol. 17, sec. C, pp. 227–234.
50. Esin D.N. Some Upper Permian paleoniscids from the collection of the Geological and Mineralogical Museum of Kazan University. Byull. MOIP. Otd. Geol., 1995, vol. 70, no. 1, pp. 69–90. (In Russian)
51. Esin D.N. Early Kazanian paleoniscids from north European Russian and the Kama Region. Paleontol. J., 1995, vol. 29, no. 2, pp. 147–165.
52. Esin D.N. Late Permian paleoniscoids of European Russia. Cand. Geol.–Mineral. Sci. Diss. Moscow, 1995. 350 p. (In Russian)
53. Minikh A.V. Novye lucheperye ryby iz tatarskogo yarusa basseina r. Sukhony i Yuzhnogo Priural’ya [New Ray-Finned Fishes from the Tatarian Stage of the Sukhona River Basin and the Southern Urals]. Saratov, Izd. Sarat. Univ., 1995. 18 p. Deposited with VINITI on May 10, 1995, no. 1306-V95. (In Russian)
54. Minikh A.V., Minikh M.G. Pozdnepermskie ryby Prikazanskogo Povolzh’ya [Late Permian Fishes of the Kazan Volga Region]. Saratov, Izd. Sarat. Univ., 1995. 16 p. Deposited with VINITI on May 10, 1995, no. 1303-V95. (In Russian)
55. Yankevich D.I. Novyi rod paleoniskov iz ufimskikh otlozhenii Verkhnego Prikam’ya [A New Genus of Paleoniscids from the Ufa Deposits of the Upper Kama Region]. Saratov, Sarat. Gos. Univ., 1995. 10 p. Deposited with VINITI on May 10, 1995, no. 1305-V. (In Russian)
56. Minikh A.V., Minikh M.G. Fish. In: Stratotipy i opornye razrezy verkhnei permi Povolzh’ya i Prikam’ya [Stratotypes and Reference Sections of the Upper Permian of the Volga and Kama Regions]. Esaulova N.K., Lozovskii V.R. (Eds.). Kazan, Ekotsentr, 1996. pp. 258–269. (In Russian)
57. Yankevich D.I. Novye ryby iz ufimskikh otlozhenii Permskogo Prikam’ya [New Fish from the Ufa Deposits of the Perm Kama Region]. Saratov, Izd. Sarat. Univ., 1996. 13 p. Deposited with VINITI on July 10, 1996, no. 2279-V96.
58. Esin D.N., Mashin V.L. Ichthyolites. In: Stratotipy i opornye razrezy verkhnei permi Povolzh’ya i Prikam’ya [Stratotypes and Reference Sections of the Upper Permian of the Volga and Kama River Regions]. Esaulova N.K., Lozovskii V.R. (Eds.). Kazan, Ekotsentr, 1996. pp. 270–291. (In Russian)
59. Minikh M.G. Stages in the development of the Late Permian and Triassic ichthyofauna of European Russia and stratigraphic ichthyocomplexes. Uch. Zap. Geol. Fak. Sarat. Univ. Nov. Ser., 1997, no. 1, pp. 67–77. (In Russian)
60. Esin D.N. Peculiarities of trophic orientation changes in palaeoniscoid assemblages from the Upper Permian of the European part of Russia. Mod. Geol., 1997, vol. 21, no. 1, pp. 185–195.

For other references see (total number of references: 95) 

The content is available under the license Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.