KFU. Card publication. Semantic and metasemantic notions of analyticity

KAZAN
FEDERAL UNIVERSITY

- RUS
- 中文
- ES

SEMANTIC AND METASEMANTIC NOTIONS OF ANALYTICITY

Form of presentation

Articles in international journals and collections

Year of publication

2014

Authors, employees of KFU

Karimov Artur Ravilevich, author

Other authors

Kazakova V.A.

Bibliographic description in the original language

Karimov, A.R., Kazakova V.A. Semantic and metasemantic notions of analyticity. Asian Social Science. Vol.10, No. 22, 2014. Pages 285-290.

Annotation

In this article the evolution of main conceptions of analyticity is analyzed. Kant?s criteria for analytic/synthetic distinction are discussed. Frege and Carnap notions of analyticity are set out. It is shown that Frege and Carnap shifted the criteria of analyticity to the justificatory status of judgments. The notion of truth in virtue of meaning and its criticism is exposed. Critical arguments against analyticity by W. V. O. Quine are discussed. Williamson?s arguments against traditional notions of analyticity are formulated. Williamson maintains that analytic truths are reduced to truths of other base classes-necessary, semantic or logical. It is shown that the stipulative definition of analyticity is vulnerable to Williamson?s argument. Russell?s conception of truth in virtue of reference determiner is exposed and evaluated. It is defended that the notion of truth in virtue of reference determiner is immune to many standard objections against analyticity.

Keywords

analyticity, meaning, stipulation, reference

The name of the journal

Asian Social Science

URL

http://dx.doi.org/10.5539/ass.v10n22p285

Please use this ID to quote from or refer to the card

https://repository.kpfu.ru/eng/?p_id=89837&p_lang=2

Resource files

File name	Size (MB)	Format
41750_143267_1_SM.pdf	0,14	pdf	show / download

Full metadata record

Field DC	Value	Language
dc.contributor.author	Karimov Artur Ravilevich	ru_RU
dc.date.accessioned	2014-01-01T00:00:00Z	ru_RU
dc.date.available	2014-01-01T00:00:00Z	ru_RU
dc.date.issued	2014	ru_RU
dc.identifier.citation	Karimov, A.R., Kazakova V.A. Semantic and metasemantic notions of analyticity. Asian Social Science. Vol.10, No. 22, 2014. Pages 285-290.	ru_RU
dc.identifier.uri	https://repository.kpfu.ru/eng/?p_id=89837&p_lang=2	ru_RU
dc.description.abstract	Asian Social Science	ru_RU
dc.description.abstract	In this article the evolution of main conceptions of analyticity is analyzed. Kant?s criteria for analytic/synthetic distinction are discussed. Frege and Carnap notions of analyticity are set out. It is shown that Frege and Carnap shifted the criteria of analyticity to the justificatory status of judgments. The notion of truth in virtue of meaning and its criticism is exposed. Critical arguments against analyticity by W. V. O. Quine are discussed. Williamson?s arguments against traditional notions of analyticity are formulated. Williamson maintains that analytic truths are reduced to truths of other base classes-necessary, semantic or logical. It is shown that the stipulative definition of analyticity is vulnerable to Williamson?s argument. Russell?s conception of truth in virtue of reference determiner is exposed and evaluated. It is defended that the notion of truth in virtue of reference determiner is immune to many standard objections against analyticity.	ru_RU
dc.language.iso	ru	ru_RU
dc.subject	analyticity	ru_RU
dc.subject	meaning	ru_RU
dc.subject	stipulation	ru_RU
dc.subject	reference	ru_RU
dc.title	Semantic and metasemantic notions of analyticity	ru_RU
dc.type	Articles in international journals and collections	ru_RU